What to drink when you don't know what you want
A Warmery guide to choosing tea, coffee or hot chocolate by mood, moment and what you feel like right now
Sometimes you don't know what you want
There are moments when you know you want a drink, but you have absolutely no idea what kind.
Coffee sounds good, but perhaps not quite right. Tea feels too ordinary. Hot chocolate sounds tempting, but maybe a little too indulgent for the middle of the afternoon.
So you stand in front of the cupboard for a while, looking at everything, somehow feeling less certain than when you started.
It is a surprisingly familiar feeling.
Perhaps the problem is that we usually ask ourselves the wrong question.
Instead of asking "What should I drink?", try asking "What do I want this moment to feel like?"
Maybe you need something comforting. Maybe you want to feel a little more refreshed. Perhaps you are craving something cosy, need a gentle lift or simply fancy something that feels like a treat.
And sometimes you might want to step completely outside your usual choice and try something you've never had before.
There is no perfect answer, and no rule says coffee belongs to mornings, tea to afternoons, or hot chocolate to evenings.
The best drink is often the one that fits you, right now.
So rather than giving you another list of drinks to try, this guide starts somewhere a little different.
Start with how you feel, and let the drink follow.
The mood comes first
Choosing a drink doesn't always start with flavour.
Sometimes it starts with the moment you are in.
You might be sitting at your desk and realise you need a proper pause. You might be watching the rain and want something warm and comforting. Perhaps you have just finished work and want something that helps mark the transition into a slower evening. Or maybe you simply fancy trying something different because your usual cup feels a little predictable today.
That is why there is no single answer to what you should drink.
Tea, coffee, and hot chocolate can all create very different experiences, even when you drink them at the same time of day. A bright, fresh tea can feel completely different from a rich, rounded coffee. A mug of hot chocolate can turn an ordinary evening into something that feels a little more special.
So before reaching for the cupboard, take a second to think about what you actually want from the moment.
Comfort. Freshness. Cosiness. A little lift. Something indulgent. Or simply something new.
Once you know that, choosing the drink becomes much easier.
And if you still cannot decide, we have made that part easy too.
Find your drink mood
What do you feel like right now?
There is no right answer. Choose the feeling that sounds most like you, and we will point you towards a drink that fits the moment.
Your moment
When you need something comforting
Some drinks feel comforting before you have even taken the first sip.
Perhaps it is the familiar warmth of a cup in your hands, the smell that fills the kitchen as you brew it, or simply knowing exactly what you are going to get.
When you are looking for that kind of moment, softer and more familiar flavours tend to work beautifully. A delicate Darjeeling can make an afternoon feel quieter, while a naturally sweet coffee can bring a little warmth to an otherwise ordinary break.
And then there are the drinks that feel almost like a treat without becoming a full occasion. Something smooth, rounded and easy to settle into.
For this kind of mood, we would look towards Quiet Mind Darjeeling Tea, Sweet Pecan Pause Coffee and Snug Caramel Sip Coffee.
The important thing is not choosing the drink that sounds most impressive. It is choosing the one that makes you want to slow down for a few minutes.
When you need something refreshing
Sometimes you do not want a drink that feels heavy or especially cosy. You want something that feels like opening a window and letting a little fresh air into the room.
This is where brighter, cleaner flavours come through.
Mint can bring a cool, fresh character to a quiet pause. Lemon and ginger add a little more warmth and citrus. Green tea offers a lighter, more delicate option when you want something simple and clean.
For this kind of moment, try Cool Mind Mint Tea, Fresh Lift Hug Lemon and Ginger Tea or Calm Green Pause Tea.
You might reach for one after lunch, during a crowded afternoon, or simply because you want something that tastes different from your usual cup.
No need to make the moment complicated. Sometimes refreshing means exactly that. A different flavour, a few quiet minutes and a chance to reset before carrying on.
Make it a moment
Build your cosy moment
There is no perfect way to do cosy. Choose what sounds good to you, and we will put the moment together.
01
Your drink
02
Your setting
03
Your companion
Your cosy moment
Choose your three ingredients
Pick a drink, a setting and something to accompany the moment.
Your little ritual
Choose one option from each section and we will create your little cosy ritual.
A change of pace
When you need a little lift
Sometimes you do not need a completely different day. You just need a small change of pace.
Choose the kind of lift that sounds right, and find a drink to match it.
Your little lift
Choose what sounds good
Pick an option above and we will find the drink to match it.
Try
Your moment
A little treat
When you want something indulgent
Sometimes you are not looking for something sensible, refreshing or productive. You simply want something that feels like a treat.
01
Go all in
For the proper chocolate moment
Dreamy Drift Drops
Rich, chocolatey and made for the moments when you want something that feels properly indulgent.
Explore the drink
02
Something softer
For a gentler kind of treat
Cloud Hug Drops
Sweet, creamy and wonderfully gentle when you fancy something a little different.
Explore the drink
03
A familiar favourite
For an easy chocolate comfort
Mellow Mood Cocoa
Warm, comforting and easy to settle into when all you really want is a lovely cup of chocolate.
Explore the drink
When you want to try something different
Sometimes the best choice is the one you would not normally make.
If you always reach for the same coffee, choosing something from a different origin can make the whole ritual feel new again. Brazil, Indonesia, Kenya and Ethiopia can all bring very different characteristics to the cup, which is part of what makes exploring coffee so enjoyable.
You do not need to know exactly what you are looking for. You can simply start with somewhere you have never tried before.
Perhaps that means the distinctive character of Toba Toast Sip Indonesian Coffee, the bright character of Glow Ground Kenyan Coffee, the curiosity of Curious Spirit Ethiopian Yirgacheffe, or the easygoing character of Brazilian Breezy Beam Coffee.
There is no right choice. Sometimes the fun is simply seeing where your next cup takes you.
Still not sure? That's okay.
You have considered comfort, freshness, cosiness, something different, and something indulgent, and somehow you still don't know what you want.
That is completely fine.
You do not need to find the perfect drink. There is no prize for making the most thoughtful choice, and no rule saying you have to try something new every time.
Sometimes the best choice is simply the drink you already know you enjoy.
If that means making the same coffee you have had all week, choosing your favourite tea or treating yourself to hot chocolate on a Tuesday afternoon, that is still a perfectly good choice.
The point is not to choose perfectly. It is to enjoy the moment you have chosen.
So if you are still standing in front of the cupboard wondering what you fancy, go with the first thing that made you think, " That sounds good.
You can always try something different tomorrow.
Your quick guide
A simple mood based drink guide
Still not sure what to reach for? Keep it simple.
Start with how you feel, then choose the drink that sounds most appealing. There is no need to overthink it. Your mood is enough of a reason.
| If you're feeling... | Try... | Make it your moment |
|---|---|---|
| In need of comfort | Quiet Mind Darjeeling | A quiet afternoon with a book |
| Ready for something fresh | Cool Mind Mint or Fresh Lift Hug | A little pause between tasks |
| In the mood for cosy | Cosy Chunky Chai | Rain at the window |
| In need of a little lift | Glow Ground Kenyan | A change of pace in the afternoon |
| Ready for a treat | Dreamy Drift Drops | A slow evening with your favourite mug |
| Curious to try something new | Curious Spirit Ethiopian | A slow weekend coffee ritual |
| Still completely unsure | Your usual favourite | Whatever moment you have right now |
Remember
There is no perfect choice. The best drink is often simply the one you actually want.
There is no perfect drink
Sometimes choosing what to drink is surprisingly complicated.
You stand in front of the cupboard, consider every option, and somehow end up wanting none of them.
But perhaps choosing a drink was never really about finding the perfect answer.
Maybe you simply need to ask yourself what you want from the next few minutes.
Something comforting. Something fresh. Something cosy. A little lift. A treat. Or perhaps just something different.
And if none of those feels right, there is always your usual favourite.
The point is not to make every cup meaningful or turn every drink into a ritual. It is simply to give yourself permission to choose something that feels right for you, right now.
So make the drink you actually fancy. Find somewhere comfortable to sit. And let the next few minutes belong to you.
After all, sometimes the smallest choices are the ones that help us create a moment that feels like yours again.
FAQs
What should I drink when I don't know what I want?
Start with how you want the moment to feel rather than choosing by drink type. If you want comfort, something soft and familiar, like Darjeeling tea or a naturally sweet coffee, could work. For freshness, try mint, lemon and ginger or green tea. If you want something cosy, chai is a lovely choice, while hot chocolate works beautifully if you want something more indulgent.
How do I choose between tea and coffee?
Think about the flavour and experience you are craving. Tea can feel lighter and more delicate, while coffee can offer something richer, deeper or more aromatic. Neither is automatically better for a particular time of day. Choose whichever sounds appealing in that moment.
What is a good drink when I want something comforting?
Look for familiar, rounded flavours you can settle into without thinking too much. Quiet Mind Darjeeling Tea, Sweet Pecan Pause Coffee, and Snug Caramel Sip Coffee all fit that slower, comforting moment.
What should I drink if I want something refreshing?
Brighter flavours are a good place to start. Cool Mind Mint Tea brings a fresh, cooling character, while Fresh Lift Hug Lemon and Ginger Tea offers citrus and gentle warmth. Calm Green Pause Tea is another option if you prefer something lighter and delicate.
Do I have to choose a different drink every time?
Absolutely not. Sometimes the drink you want is the one you already know you love. Choosing the same tea or coffee again does not make the moment any less enjoyable. The purpose of choosing by mood is simply to help you find something that feels right, not to make every cup a new experience.
Cupside Thoughts
View all-
What to drink when you don't know what you want
Not sure what you fancy? Instead of choosing by time of day, start with how you feel. Discover how to choose tea, coffee or hot chocolate for moments when you...
What to drink when you don't know what you want
Not sure what you fancy? Instead of choosing by time of day, start with how you feel. Discover how to choose tea, coffee or hot chocolate for moments when you...
-
Best Autumn Teas, Coffees & Hot Chocolates
From warming chai and comforting coffee to rich hot chocolate, discover the drinks that make autumn feel a little cosier. Find the right drink for crisp mornings, rainy afternoons, quiet...
Best Autumn Teas, Coffees & Hot Chocolates
From warming chai and comforting coffee to rich hot chocolate, discover the drinks that make autumn feel a little cosier. Find the right drink for crisp mornings, rainy afternoons, quiet...
-
What constant notifications are doing to your mind
Do you instinctively check your phone every time it buzzes? Discover what constant notifications may be doing to your attention and mental wellbeing, why digital overload feels so exhausting and...
What constant notifications are doing to your mind
Do you instinctively check your phone every time it buzzes? Discover what constant notifications may be doing to your attention and mental wellbeing, why digital overload feels so exhausting and...
